Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming how advancement professionals engage, strategize, and fundraise. With the right digital infrastructure in place, AI doesn’t just offer incremental improvements—it unlocks a path toward full digital transformation. In an increasingly competitive and fast-changing philanthropic landscape, this transformation is essential to staying relevant and responsive. For advancement shops exploring how to harness AI effectively, here are five essential insights to guide your AI strategy.

‍

1. Distinguish Between Preparation and Purpose in Pursuit of AI 🏃

Purpose: The Strategic Anchor

Purpose must come first. It defines why AI is being pursued in the first place. Is the goal to enhance personalization in donor engagement? Automate time-consuming processes? Identify patterns in giving behavior? Increase operational efficiency?

Establishing a well-defined purpose sets the trajectory for all downstream decisions. It informs which data needs to be collected, what quality standards must be upheld, which tools or platforms are suitable, and what kind of expertise will be required. Without a clearly articulated purpose, efforts around AI can become unfocused, resource-intensive, and ultimately underwhelming in impact.

Preparation: The Tactical Foundation

Too often, organizations allow perceived deficiencies in data or infrastructure to stall progress. They mistakenly assume that AI can only begin once every dataset is pristine, every field is normalized, and every system is interoperable. In reality, preparation is rarely perfect—and it need not be. What matters is that preparation is guided by the defined purpose. Data does not have to be universally clean; it has to be fit for purpose. The right AI partner can assist in transforming and optimizing what exists to align with that purpose.

Why This Distinction Matters

Failing to separate preparation from purpose can lead to strategic paralysis. Teams may find themselves investing heavily in data-cleaning exercises or systems integration projects without knowing what they are working toward. Alternatively, organizations might rush into implementing AI tools without the requisite data frameworks in place, leading to superficial results or misalignment with organizational goals.

By establishing purpose as the driver and preparation as the enabler, organizations can prioritize effectively, invest wisely, and build a phased approach to AI adoption that evolves with their capabilities.

‍

2. AI is Not a Magic Bullet ✨

While artificial intelligence—particularly machine learning—holds immense potential, it’s important to understand that it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Machine learning is a solution primarily used in the areas where traditional programming does not offer a viable solution, like when the nature of information availability is dynamic (ex: predicting donor behavior). Learning is an iterative process, even for machines, it takes time and adjustment to get it right, it's not an easy button. 

Success is rarely the result of a single tool or tactic. Instead, it’s the outcome of many integrated efforts across personalized outreach, digital engagement, predictive analytics, and more.When evaluating solutions, the most critical factor is not flashy features, but rather the system’s ability to move and integrate data effectively. Without that, even the most sophisticated AI won’t be able to deliver meaningful results. It is the cumulative impact of many different channels and tools that contribute to overall success, rarely is it a one solution magic bullet. The critical criteria of the solutions you choose is ability to move data. 

‍

3. Flexible Digital Infrastructure is Key 🤸

One of the biggest barriers to effective AI adoption in advancement is outdated, rigid infrastructure. Legacy systems often suffer from unnecessary complexity and fragmented data stored in silos—conditions that are incompatible with how AI learns and operates. For AI to deliver real, lasting value, it requires continuous access to comprehensive, connected data across your organization.

Without the right infrastructure, even the most promising AI tools may show short-term gains but ultimately fall short as they struggle to scale or adapt. A flexible digital infrastructure, by contrast, not only supports the seamless movement and integration of your existing data—it also generates new data that can enhance future performance. The result? A system that not only accommodates AI, but also revitalizes legacy technologies and sets the stage for ongoing innovation.

‍

4. The Power of AI Lies in the Questions You Ask 🤔

Artificial intelligence is a powerful tool—but its effectiveness depends on how strategically it is applied. Too often, organizations focus on the capabilities of AI without first clarifying what they truly want to achieve. Without a clear line of inquiry, AI can generate irrelevant or surface-level insights that don’t move the needle. Are you trying to identify donors with the highest likelihood to re-engage? Understand the timing and channel preferences of major gift prospects? Detect early indicators of donor attrition? The specificity of your questions will guide the AI to surface the insights that matter most.

Why Specificity Matters

AI models excel when fed with defined parameters and measurable objectives. Vague or overly broad goals lead to generalized output, which can result in analysis paralysis or misinformed strategies. Specific questions provide focus. They allow teams to prioritize the right datasets, refine predictive models, and generate insights that support their goals.

‍

5. Cultivating a Culture of Growth Mindset is Essential 🌱

Cultivating an organizational environment where learning, adaptability, and continuous improvement are valued and actively encouraged at every level is essential to equip teams to adopt and adapt to AI. Organizations get the best outcomes when they are willing to test, iterate, and learn continuously. When guided by thoughtful questions and a learning mindset, AI becomes far more than a technical solution—it becomes a strategic asset for decision-making and long-term growth.

Contrary to the belief that experimentation increases risk, a culture of experimentation actually manages risk by allowing small, controlled tests before large-scale implementation. Piloting an AI-driven stewardship model, for instance, provides critical feedback on what works—and what doesn’t—without the need for sweeping, unproven changes.

These iterative cycles foster a learning environment where data informs decision-making, outcomes are measured, and continuous improvement becomes part of the organizational DNA.